Russian troop pull-out not enough, EU leaders say (Roundup)

Oct 16, 2008, 13:15 GMT

Brussels - European Union leaders agreed Thursday to harden their common stance towards Russia by saying its withdrawal from core Georgia was not a sufficient reason to re-open talks on a cooperation deal with Moscow.

While welcoming the Russian pull-out from the areas adjacent to the separatist enclaves of South Ossetia and Abkhazia, leaders meeting for a summit in Brussels insisted that this was only an 'essential supplementary step' for the implementation of international peace accords.

'All 27 EU member states welcome the withdrawals while recognizing that they do not completely finish Russia's commitment under the peace plan of August 12,' said British Foreign Minister David Miliband.

The insistence by Britain, Sweden and the Baltic nations that Russia needs to do more risks dashing the hopes of those politicians who want a quick re-start of talks on a key strategic deal with Russia.

At an emergency summit held on September 1, EU leaders decided to freeze further talks on a Partnership and Cooperation Agreement (PCA) with Russia 'until (its) troops have withdrawn to positions they held prior to August 7,' when the war broke out.

Since then, EU nations have split between those who argue that Russia's withdrawal from core Georgia is enough to re-start PCA talks, and those who say Russia would also have to scale down its strengthened presence in the two separatist enclaves.

On Thursday, EU leaders effectively delayed any decision until the European Commission presents a 'full in-depth evaluation of EU-Russia relations,' to be discussed by EU foreign ministers on November 10.

That leaves foreign ministers just days to decide on a relaunch of the PCA talks ahead of an EU-Russia summit set for November 14.

Estonian Foreign Minister Urmas Paet said a number of unresolved issues still remained on the table. These include the return of internally displaced people, allowing international monitors to enter South Ossetia and Abkhazia, as well as Russia's continued presence in the disputed areas of the Kodori valley and the Akhalgori region, both of which lie on the borders between core Georgia and the two separatist enclaves.

'A lot will depend on how the Russians are going to handle this issue in the coming three to four weeks,' Paet told Deutsche Presse-Agentur dpa.

The EU summit ended a day after a first round of peace talks between Georgia and Russia collapsed in Geneva, prompting EU foreign policy chief Javier Solana to express scepticism about the chance of those talks succeeding.

'After the big tension in August, it is very difficult to get face-to-face talks. But we will do everything possible,' Solana said.

The Geneva talks, co-hosted by the EU, United Nations and Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE), are now expected to resume on November 18.

Paet did not exclude the possibility that EU foreign ministers would postpone any decision on restarting PCA talks until after the next round of Geneva talks.

The EU has sent a monitoring mission (EUMM) to Georgia to oversee Russia's withdrawal from core Georgia, as agreed in an international peace deal brokered by French President Nicolas Sarkozy.

The PCA is a contract governing matters such as trade, investment, environmental protection, tourism, and cultural exchanges between the EU and Russia.