UK Features

Litvinenko murder case set to sour London-Moscow ties

By Anna Tomforde May 22, 2007, 13:50 GMT

File picture dated 24 November 2006 shows a former officer of the Federal Security Service Andrey Lugovoy during his interview at Echo of Moscow radio station in Moscow. EPA/SERGEI CHIRIKOV

File picture dated 24 November 2006 shows a former officer of the Federal Security Service Andrey Lugovoy during his interview at Echo of Moscow radio station in Moscow. EPA/SERGEI CHIRIKOV

London - British efforts to apply the rule of law to clear up the spectacular radioactive poisoning of Alexander Litvinenko are likely to be as arduous, lengthy and painful as the very public death of the former Russian KGB spy in London six months ago.

The decision to press murder charges against Andrei Lugovoy, a Moscow-based businessman and former KGB agent now suspected of having poisoned Litvinenko with a large dose of the radioactive isotope polonium-210, is likely to lead to heightened political tension, analysts in London believe.

From a British legal point of view, the Litvinenko poisoning is to be rated as an 'extraordinarily grave crime' that requires to be treated as a criminal case, free of any political connotations.

The evidence, experts believe, is present in the 'trail of polonium' scattered all over London - from a football stadium to a hotel room and a British Airways plane.

British commentators were keen to stress Tuesday that the murder charges recommended by the Crown Prosecution Service were directed at an 'individual,' and in no way implied that British investigators suspected any 'state involvement' in the Litvinenko murder.

'This remains a legal matter,' a Foreign Office official said.

However, despite such efforts at 'showing restraint,' there can be no doubt that 'politics are lurking' in the Litvinenko case and that both sides are bracing themselves for fresh tensions over the murky killing.

British commentators concede that, coming at a highly-sensitive time in Russia's relations with the West, the public revival of the Litvinenko case could put bilateral relations 'into cold storage' for some time.

But the authorities hope that, by sticking to their conviction that they are dealing with a 'classic case' of the rule of law being applied to a criminal case, they can force Moscow onto the defensive.

On his deathbed, Litvinenko himself let the world know that he, at least, placed his fate in a political context.

'You may succeed in silencing one man, but the howl of protest from around the world will reverberate, Mr Putin, in your ears for the rest of your life,' he wrote.

'This was a serious crime. We are seeking and expect full co- operation from the Russian authorities,' said Margaret Beckett, Britain's Foreign Secretary.

Similarly defiant language came from the office of Prime Minister Tony Blair, who will, however, leave it to his likely successor, Gordon Brown, to tackle the political consequences of the Litvinenko affair.

Attempts by London to contain the expected political fall-out received an immediate rebuff from Moscow when Russia's Prosecutor General's Office repeated its well-known position that Russian law does not permit a citizen to be 'given to a foreign state.'

Lugovoy, it can be assumed, will be safe running his private security firm as long as he stays in Russia, but could be arrested if he ventured abroad.

British sources said Tuesday that it was 'highly unlikely' that a deal would be struck with Moscow over the extradition of exiled Russian tycoon Boris Berezovsky in return for Lugovoy.

The Russian government, which believes that Berezovsky played a key role in 'setting up' the high-profile Litvinenko murder, has repeatedly asked London to hand him over.

'It is hard to see a deal being done. What will happen is stalemate on the legal front and a political war or words between the two sides,' said one analyst.

© 2007 dpa - Deutsche Presse-Agentur


COMMENT

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest Headlines in UK

Older Talkback

page: 1 

who killed the ex spyJun 5th, 2007 - 10:01:32

READ ON

who killed the ex-russian spyJun 5th, 2007 - 02:22:22

Read on:-

Andrei Lugovoi Gives His Version of Events
// Accuses British Intelligence, Boris Berezovsky, and Russian Mafia
Of the Murder of Alexander Litvinenko
Russian businessmen Andrei Lugovoi and Dmitry Kovtun, who have been accused, respectively, by Great Britain of the murder of former FSB officer Alexander Litvinenko and by Germany of the illegal trafficking of radioactive materials, gave their version yesterday of the poisoning of Mr. Litvinenko in London. According to them, the participants in Mr. Litivinenko's murder could include the British intelligence services, exiled Russian oligarch Boris Berezovsky, and allies of mafia boss Zakhary Kalashov. The Russian prosecutor general's office and the FSB said that they will investigate the validity of these claims. Meanwhile, Alexander Litvinenko's father told Kommersant that his son had repeated the names of his murderers on his deathbed: Andrei Lugovoi and Dmitry Kovtun.
The British Special Services and Their Agents

For the press conference, which was broadcast live around the world, Andrei Lugovoi and Dmitry Kovtun turned up twenty minutes late, ducking into the room in a circle of bodyguards from Tenth Wave, Mr. Lugovoi's company. After he had taken his seat behind a bank of microphones, Mr. Lugovoi began to read from a page of prepared remarks. 'Today I am ready to make a statement that should shed some light on the murky political history in which the British special services and their agents, Berezovsky and the deceased Litvinenko, play a lead role,' he said. According to Mr. Lugovoi, last spring he met in London with Alexander Litvinenko, who told him that he had been an agent of the British special services for several years. Mr. Litvinenko purportedly brought representatives of MI6 into contact with Boris Berezovsky, who agreed to pass secret documents to British Intelligence in exchange for political asylum. 'Boris Abramovich [Berezovsky] gave the British some documents from the Russian Security Council (Mr. Berezovsky was the deputy secretary of the Security Council from October 1996 to November 1997) and also became an agent of MI6. After that, the question of being granted asylum and receiving British citizenship became nothing but a technicality,' said Mr. Lugovoi.

According to Mr. Lugovoi, Alexander Litvinenko suggested that he work for MI6 as well by collecting compromising information about Russian politicians, including President Putin. He claims he was told that 'the road to Great Britain would be closed and business channels in Europe blocked' for him if he did not agree. In order to carry out his assignments, he was given a mobile telephone and a copy of Yevgeny Grishkovets' book Rubashka, with which he was supposed to encode his communications with London, 'like in spy movies.' Mr. Lugovoi, however, claims that he 'was taught to defend the Motherland, not betray it,' and he maintains that he did not gather compromising intelligence about the president, though he retained his contacts with Mr. Litvinenko. Also in 2006, Mr. Lugovoi introduced Mr. Litvinenko to Dmitry Kovtun, who said yesterday that he had repeatedly heard from Mr. Litvinenko that he was dissatisfied with Boris Berezovsky, who had reduced his 'support payments from 5,000 pounds a month to 1,500.' According to Lugovoi and Kovtun, Alexander Litvinenko had even intended to blackmail Berezovsky, using documents about his 'illegal activities on UK territory.' Mr. Kovtun added, 'Litvinenko said that he decided all sorts of matters in the Caucasus' and had been several times to the Pankisi Gorge, a hotbed of separatist rebellion in Georgia. 'Litvinenko was in Istanbul at the behest of Ahmed Zakayev, where he met with several representatives of Chechen rebel groups,' agreed Mr. Lugovoi, adding that 'Litvinenko was also in Nalchik,' a town in southern Russia where an attack on Russian security forces on October 13, 2005 resulted in the deaths of at least 136 people, including, according to Andrei Lugovoi, 78 FSB officers.

Picking up the main thread of his narrative, Andrei Lugovoi claimed that neither he nor Dmitry Kovtun had a motive to kill Alexander Litvinenko, but that Boris Berezovsky and the British special services did: they wanted to liquidate an agent who talked too much. Mr. Lugovoi also did not rule out the involvement of the Russian mafia, which 'could have avenged itself on Litvinenko in such a barbaric manner' for his cooperation with the Spanish police after the former FSB officer helped them arrest the mafia boss Zakhary Kalashov.

Lugovoi and Kovtun have no intention of going to Britain or Germany to answer the charges in person, but they claim they are ready to appear in a Russian court. Andrei Lugovoi alleged that the actions of the British Crown Prosecution Service have cost him $25 million in moral and material damages and that he was 'obliged to sell his stake in a factory in Ryazan Oblast that manufactures non-alcoholic beverages' as a result of the accusations.

A highly-placed source close to the Russian leadership told Kommersant yesterday that '[the press conference] was all some kind of nonsense, they're rummaging around for something and then they just say whatever… It's just garbage!' However, the Russian prosecutor general's office and the FSB said yesterday that they will follow up on the leads provided by Mr. Lugovoi as part of 'their own' investigation into the poisoning of Alexander Litvinenko.

'Sasha said, 'Lugovoi and Kovtun poisoned me''

The 'nonsense' that so disgusted the source in the Kremlin could refer not only to the suspicions voiced by Lugovoi and Kovtun but also to the 'facts' cited by the two businessmen as proof of their version of events, which seriously undermine any trust in what they have to say. It is generally known that, after he emigrated to the UK in 2000, Alexander Litvinenko could not travel back to Russia, meaning that he could not possibly have participated in the attack in Nalchik in 2005. The prosecutor's office in the Russian autonomous region of Kabardino-Balkaria, of which Nalchik is the capital, told Kommersant that the name Litvinenko does not appear on their list of suspects. The office also formally denied that any FSB officers were among the dead: according to official reports, 92 militants, 35 law enforcement officers, and 12 civilians were killed in the attack.

Ahmed Zakayev, on whose orders Alexander Litvinenko supposedly carried out missions in Istanbul, the Pankisi Gorge, and Nalchik, told Kommersant, 'Sasha wasn't there on my orders or for any other reason.' 'Mr. Lugovoi could not professionally fulfill the task of liquidating Alexander Litvinenko; he left a trail, and now he and the people who ordered this crime are attempting to bluff their way out,' believes Mr. Zakayev. 'At first the Russian special services explained the polonium-210 by saying that Litvinenko was supposedly acting on my behest to arm Chechen rebels with a dirty bomb,' he recalled.

Alexander Litvinenko's father Walter dismissed the alleged involvement of the British special services in the death of his son as nonsense. 'I spent several days and nights with Sasha in the hospital, and he told me all the details about his friends and enemies, about who killed him and how,' said the elder Mr. Litvinenko. 'He said nothing about the British special services, and, as a rule, doomed men do not lie,' he added. Walter Litvinenko also believes that the suspicions aimed at Boris Berezovsky do not hold water: 'Boris is a warm-hearted man, and he always helped my son. They were good friends, and I will never believe that they could do anything bad to each other.' Speaking of Alexander Litvinenko in the days before he died, Walter Litvinenko remembered that his son had repeatedly named his killers: 'Sasha said, 'Andrei Lugovoi and Dmitry Kovtun poisoned me, I trusted them, and they deceived me.''

Boris Berezovsky denied any ties to MI6 and told Kommersant that he has nothing against Mr. Lugovoi personally, saying that Mr. Lugovoi ceased to be an independent agent a long time ago: 'During my last telephone call with him, I became convinced that someone was standing behind him and dictating, and Andrei was just parroting the words,' he said. Berezovsky claims to feel sorry for Andrei Lugovoi, who turned out to be 'a pawn in a big political battle and the executor of this crime' and who now has a sword dangling over his head.

Businessman Alimjan Tokhtakhunov, a close associate of Zakhary Kalashov, told Kommersant that while he believes Alexander Litvinenko 'of course would have had to earn his political asylum in England, maybe by working as an agent [of MI6],' the idea that anyone from Kalashov's circle was involved in his murder is a 'fairytale.'

The British Foreign Office declined to comment on Andrei Lugovoi's statements accusing agents of MI6 of complicity in the murder of Alexander Litvinenko. A spokesperson said only that the case is purely a criminal matter that has nothing to do with espionage or the intelligence services. The Foreign Office also noted that the Russian authorities have been served extradition papers for Mr. Lugovoi, who is wanted to stand trial in the UK. Yesterday a spokesperson from the US National Security Council said that the US supports the British request, given that the matter involves a very serious crime.
World
Russian Spy Blames MI6 for Litvinenko's Death
by Gregory Feifer

All Things Considered, May 31, 2007 · The man British authorities charged with poisoning former KGB officer Alexander Litvinenko has responded with his own accusations.

Andrei Lugovoi, another former KGB officer, says Litvinenko was a British agent who was trying to gather compromising materials about Russian President Vladimir Putin.

Lugovoi said the British intelligence service MI6 was unhappy with Litvinenko — and might have known about a plot to silence him and frame Lugovoi.

Suspect in Spy Death Points Finger at MI6
A Russian businessman, accused by the British of poisoning ex-KGB spy Alexander Litvinenko, says he is being framed for the murder by the British intelligence agency.

Andrei Lugovoi said the British intelligence agency was aware of the plot to kill Litvinenko and even had a hand in the murder. Lugovoi also said he has evidence of London's involvement in the death of Litvinenko, who was dosed with radioactive polonium-210.

Speaking to reporters in Moscow, Lugovoi said, 'I'm certain about one thing. The British special services had to at least know of the plot against him. Even if (British special services) hadn't done it itself, it was done under its control or connivance.'

Lugovoi did not elaborate on his evidence. The Russian government has refused Britain's requests to extradite the former spy.

Litvinenko, who received British citizenship after fleeing Russia, was a strong critic of the Kremlin. He died in November.

Last week, British officials said they had enough evidence to charge Lugovoi, who also worked for the KGB and its main successor agency, the FSB, in the murder.

Lugovoi, however, said the killing was part of an effort by British intelligence to discredit Russia and President Vladimir Putin.

'The British asked me to collect any compromising information about President Putin and members of his family,' Lugovoi said. 'It was a standard recruitment attempt with intelligence and political motives against Russia and its president.'

Lugovoi said the attempted recruitment occurred during business trips to Britain. He did not give a precise date, but indicated the alleged approach occurred in late 2005 or early 2006.

A British government security official, who demanded anonymity in exchange for discussing Lugovoi's claims, told The Associated Press suggestions that British intelligence was involved in Litvinenko's death were spurious.

London's Foreign Office, responsible for the country's overseas secret intelligence service MI6, declined to comment on Lugovoi's claim. But another government official with knowledge of Lugovoi, who also demanded anonymity because of the sensitivity of the case, said the allegations were untrue.

I AM SURE IT IS JUST LIKE DIANA, MI6 THOUGHT, THEY COULD HIODE THE MURDER JUST LIKE THAT OF DIANA'S.


NUMBER2

ANOTHER STORYJun 5th, 2007 - 02:23:58

MI6, IT IS NOT DEATH OF DIANA, THAT YOU CAN HIDE;

World
Russian Spy Blames MI6 for Litvinenko's Death
by Gregory Feifer

All Things Considered, May 31, 2007 · The man British authorities charged with poisoning former KGB officer Alexander Litvinenko has responded with his own accusations.

Andrei Lugovoi, another former KGB officer, says Litvinenko was a British agent who was trying to gather compromising materials about Russian President Vladimir Putin.

Lugovoi said the British intelligence service MI6 was unhappy with Litvinenko — and might have known about a plot to silence him and frame Lugovoi.

Suspect in Spy Death Points Finger at MI6
A Russian businessman, accused by the British of poisoning ex-KGB spy Alexander Litvinenko, says he is being framed for the murder by the British intelligence agency.

Andrei Lugovoi said the British intelligence agency was aware of the plot to kill Litvinenko and even had a hand in the murder. Lugovoi also said he has evidence of London's involvement in the death of Litvinenko, who was dosed with radioactive polonium-210.

Speaking to reporters in Moscow, Lugovoi said, 'I'm certain about one thing. The British special services had to at least know of the plot against him. Even if (British special services) hadn't done it itself, it was done under its control or connivance.'

Lugovoi did not elaborate on his evidence. The Russian government has refused Britain's requests to extradite the former spy.

Litvinenko, who received British citizenship after fleeing Russia, was a strong critic of the Kremlin. He died in November.

Last week, British officials said they had enough evidence to charge Lugovoi, who also worked for the KGB and its main successor agency, the FSB, in the murder.

Lugovoi, however, said the killing was part of an effort by British intelligence to discredit Russia and President Vladimir Putin.

'The British asked me to collect any compromising information about President Putin and members of his family,' Lugovoi said. 'It was a standard recruitment attempt with intelligence and political motives against Russia and its president.'

Lugovoi said the attempted recruitment occurred during business trips to Britain. He did not give a precise date, but indicated the alleged approach occurred in late 2005 or early 2006.

A British government security official, who demanded anonymity in exchange for discussing Lugovoi's claims, told The Associated Press suggestions that British intelligence was involved in Litvinenko's death were spurious.

London's Foreign Office, responsible for the country's overseas secret intelligence service MI6, declined to comment on Lugovoi's claim. But another government official with knowledge of Lugovoi, who also demanded anonymity because of the sensitivity of the case, said the allegations were untrue.


Report this comment

POOR BRITTS GOT EXPOSEDJun 17th, 2007 - 15:49:34

The thought that their intelligence could hide like it happenedd in Diana murder, that they murdered and got away with it.

POOR DIANA!

Report this comment

page: 1 

Follow Us

Follow M&C on Pinterest

Search

Custom Search

Also Check Out

Delta Goodrem opens up about Brian split

Delta Goodrem opens up about Brian split
Delta Goodrem said she 'didn't know how to get out' of her six and a half year relationship with Brian McFadden. ... more

Cynthia Nixon weds longtime partner

Cynthia Nixon weds longtime partner
Happy news for Cynthia Nixon and her longtime partner Christine Marinoni, parents of Max Ellington Nixon-Marinoni. The couple wed this weekend. ... more

David Beckham likes to bite Harper

David Beckham likes to bite Harper
David Beckham likes to bite his 10-month-old baby daughter, Harper, because she's so adorable. ... more

Jessica Biel is 'one of the guys'

Jessica Biel is one of the guys
Justin Timberlake's friends like his fiancee Jessica Biel because she's 'one of the guys', says his former *NSYNC bandmate Lance Bass. ... more

Lindsay Lohan pursued for 41k owed to tanning company

Lindsay Lohan pursued for 41k owed to tanning company
Lindsay Lohan still hasn't paid the $41,031 she owes to fake tan company Tanning Vegas and they are attempting to move the case from Nevada to California to force her to settle the bill. ... more

Robert De Niro glad he didn't finish school

Robert De Niro glad he didnt finish school
Robert De Niro jokingly claimed not graduating from high school was an 'advantage' as he picked up an honorary doctorate yesterday (27.05.12). ... more

Beyonce Knowles plans to get 'chocolate wasted'

Beyonce Knowles plans to get chocolate wasted
Beyonce wants to ditch her diet and get 'chocolate wasted' after successfully shedding her baby weight. ... more

Cynthia Nixon marries

Cynthia Nixon marries
Cynthia Nixon married her long-term partner Christine Marinoni in New York yesterday (2y7.05.12), her publicist has confirmed. ... more

Justin Bieber accused of assault

Justin Bieber accused of assault
Justin Bieber has been accused of assaulting a photographer in California after a physical altercation allegedly broke out when the paparazzo attempted to take pictures of the singer and his girlfriend Selena Gomez. ... more

Britney Spears' fiance makes romantic video for her

Britney Spears fiance makes romantic video for her
Britney Spears' fiancee Jason Trawick made a gushing video to tell the singer how proud he is of her US 'X Factor' debut in Austin, Texas, last week. ... more