US News

Judge rejects former CIA agent's lawsuit against Cheney, others

Jul 20, 2007, 5:39 GMT

Washington - A US federal judge on Thursday threw out a lawsuit by a former CIA agent against Vice President Dick Cheney and other top White House officials.

The judge ruled that Valerie Plame and her husband, former ambassador Joe Wilson, could not sue over leaks that led to her secret work being publicly revealed in news reports, which they claimed was retaliation for his criticism of US President George W Bush's Iraq policy following the 2003 invasion.

Cheney and the others, including Bush's top advisor, Karl Rove, and former Cheney chief of staff Lewis 'Scooter' Libby, are immune from civil liability because 'rebutting public criticism, such as that levied by Mr Wilson' is inherently part of their government work, US District Judge John Bates wrote in his decision.

Libby, convicted in March of lying in the leak investigation, was spared a 30-month prison term when Bush commuted the sentence to a fine and probation. Libby was the only person prosecuted after a lengthy investigation by a federal special prosecutor, with no indictments directly related to the leak.

© 2007 dpa - Deutsche Presse-Agentur


COMMENT

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest Headlines in US

Older Talkback

page: 1 

Rick ReynoldsJul 20th, 2007 - 06:30:01

How was what they did 'rebutting public criticism, such as that levied by Mr Wilson'? Does anyone know anything about the judge? Sounds like he may owe his job to I can only guess who.

Report this comment

danJul 20th, 2007 - 11:11:01

how convenient

Report this comment

AustinAngelaJul 20th, 2007 - 12:34:29

Convenient indeed. But don't say that our government isn't the most corrupt in the world. It isn't. Or at least that's what they're telling us to believe, so it MUST be true, right?

Report this comment

SP4; Think...Jul 20th, 2007 - 13:05:00

...'separation of powers'

Now, maybe, agent 86 and 99 will find something else to do...perhaps Joe Wilson can disguise himself as a fire hydrant or something...

Report this comment

ShadowJul 20th, 2007 - 13:25:25

Not good for the agency!
The reasoning by the judge is akin to 'Well, they have to drive a car to go to work, so it's understandable that they accidentally shot someone along the way'...

Report this comment

rootJul 20th, 2007 - 13:30:20

Hey,
If you don't like it - get the hell out. Tired of hearing your whining!

Report this comment

SP4: except for the glaring fact that...Jul 20th, 2007 - 13:55:17

...the white house aka Scoot, never actually shot anyone. Wilson and Plame are posers.

Report this comment

Dave ThomasJul 20th, 2007 - 14:50:29

More bogus mania by another anti-Bush ranter gets thrown out by the legal system. First there was the White House energy council, Valerie 'I wasn't a covert agent after my own husband outed me trying to help the Democrats' Plame, and the constant rantings by Democratic lunatics that terrorists in Guantanamo have more rights and should be allowed out to kill people.

Now the target will become the courts who have to be wrong because they don't agree with the lunatic Democrats who don't care at all about what happens to the United States just as long as they have the power to raise taxes and give away the money to their supporters.

EAT IT DEMOCRATS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! HAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Report this comment

Get over it peopleJul 20th, 2007 - 16:49:49

There was never a crime--she was a CIA desk jockey--nothing more--he was her sugerdaddy left leaning weenie--that used her influence to get the job so he could attack a sitting President.--She gets early retirement with full pay by raising all this hell, so never has to work again.
This was what thet did get
1)A political jab at the Whitehouse that let them attack the pres. and then attack scot.(real target the VP)

2) he gets a nice appointment and paycheck because of her

3)She gets early retirement, and pay for life

4) They almost got away with this suit for even more free money

5) Would really like to know is any unusual deposits were made into their accounts after this occured, or just before--think about it

Report this comment

huh?Jul 20th, 2007 - 16:50:00

My government is so embarrassing sometimes. They could have put dozens of people's lives at risk by leaking her undercover status (not to mention her life was in danger as well) Howcome the people responsible are immune? Oh, that's right, Bush is still in charge.

Report this comment

Don't pretend to be meJul 20th, 2007 - 16:57:37

I am the true Huh--and I don't agree with the above imposter

Report this comment

jillie beanJul 20th, 2007 - 21:47:17

They sell copyrights to our pet names we give ourselves on this site? I thought that 'poster' made an excellent point.

Report this comment

page: 1 

Follow Us

Follow M&C on Pinterest

Search

Custom Search

Also Check Out

Delta Goodrem opens up about Brian split

Delta Goodrem opens up about Brian split
Delta Goodrem said she 'didn't know how to get out' of her six and a half year relationship with Brian McFadden. ... more

Cynthia Nixon weds longtime partner

Cynthia Nixon weds longtime partner
Happy news for Cynthia Nixon and her longtime partner Christine Marinoni, parents of Max Ellington Nixon-Marinoni. The couple wed this weekend. ... more

David Beckham likes to bite Harper

David Beckham likes to bite Harper
David Beckham likes to bite his 10-month-old baby daughter, Harper, because she's so adorable. ... more

Jessica Biel is 'one of the guys'

Jessica Biel is one of the guys
Justin Timberlake's friends like his fiancee Jessica Biel because she's 'one of the guys', says his former *NSYNC bandmate Lance Bass. ... more

Lindsay Lohan pursued for 41k owed to tanning company

Lindsay Lohan pursued for 41k owed to tanning company
Lindsay Lohan still hasn't paid the $41,031 she owes to fake tan company Tanning Vegas and they are attempting to move the case from Nevada to California to force her to settle the bill. ... more

Robert De Niro glad he didn't finish school

Robert De Niro glad he didnt finish school
Robert De Niro jokingly claimed not graduating from high school was an 'advantage' as he picked up an honorary doctorate yesterday (27.05.12). ... more

Beyonce Knowles plans to get 'chocolate wasted'

Beyonce Knowles plans to get chocolate wasted
Beyonce wants to ditch her diet and get 'chocolate wasted' after successfully shedding her baby weight. ... more

Cynthia Nixon marries

Cynthia Nixon marries
Cynthia Nixon married her long-term partner Christine Marinoni in New York yesterday (2y7.05.12), her publicist has confirmed. ... more

Justin Bieber accused of assault

Justin Bieber accused of assault
Justin Bieber has been accused of assaulting a photographer in California after a physical altercation allegedly broke out when the paparazzo attempted to take pictures of the singer and his girlfriend Selena Gomez. ... more

Britney Spears' fiance makes romantic video for her

Britney Spears fiance makes romantic video for her
Britney Spears' fiancee Jason Trawick made a gushing video to tell the singer how proud he is of her US 'X Factor' debut in Austin, Texas, last week. ... more